The two had a cute date night following Patrick Mahomes’ 15 and Mahomies Foundation Golf Classic gala on April 27

If you thought Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce couldn’t get any cuter, their latest date-night looks have the couple’s cute-o-meter going through the roof. And they also happened to dress up as the pop star’s songs — Coincidence? We think not.

A new photo of the loved-up pair, shared by businessman Sacha Tanha on Instagram, shows them at what appears to be a private party at Toca Madera following their appearance at Patrick Mahomes’ 15 and Mahomies Foundation Golf Classic gala in Las Vegas on April 27. Mahomes’ wife, Brittany Mahomes, was also in attendance and seated next to Swift.

In the picture shared on May 1, the “Fortnite” singer, 34, wears what looks to be a black Alaïa off-the-shoulder minidress with a flared hem (Alexa, play “Dress” by Taylor Swift.)

She accessorized the flirty number with minimalist gold jewelry, including a chain necklace, bracelet and lots of rings accenting her white manicure. And of course, she rocked her signature ruby red lip, which was undoubtedly kiss-proof.

If the Grammy winner’s dress was Reputation-coded, Kelce’s outfit had Folklore written all over it.

Sticking to his comfortable style sense, the NFL star, 34, sported a white T-shirt, beige pants and a multicolor knit cardigan (get it?). He also wore a chain necklace like Swift and seemed to have topped off his outfit with the white hat in his hand.

“Tortured Poets Society. I love nice people,” wrote Tanha, the director of hospitality at Noble33, the group that’s partnering with Kelce and Mahomes on a new Kansas City steakhouse called 1587 Prime.

Fans caught a glimpse at Swift and Kelce’s gala style in footage captured by an attendee. Instead of channeling the black-and-white theme of her 11th studio album, The Tortured Poets Department, Swift decided to add a little color to her date-night wardrobe with the emerald Regina gown by Maria Lucia Hohan.

Of course, most sizes of the $2,405 gown are sold out on the label’s website but are available for preorder, so you too can make the whole place shimmer.

Swifties were also convinced that the Vitaly’s Shimmer gold choker that she wore was also a nod to a lyric in “Bejeweled.”

Kelce looked sharp in a navy suit and white shirt, which he wore with a few of the top buttons undone, giving the look a 𝓈ℯ𝓍y vibe.

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE’s free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

Besides the fashion, Kelce and Swift’s night out supplied lots of cute couple moments between the two.

When the Are You Smarter Than a Celebrity? host got up on stage to reveal Swift had put four tickets for her Eras Tour up for auction, he sweetly called her his “significant other.” In another video captured at the event, Kelce couldn’t keep his kisses in. The clip showed him planting multiple smooches on the singer’s shoulder and arm.